The Teachers Service Commission (TSC) has lost an appeal challenging a court decision that awarded a former teacher Sh975,000 for unfair dismissal following allegations of sexual harassment involving a minor.
The Employment and Labour Relations Court upheld the compensation awarded to Dominic Mwanzia Musyoka, who was dismissed in 2018 after being accused of sexually harassing a pupil at a secondary school in Makueni County. Justice Nelson Abuodha Jorum dismissed the commission’s appeal, ruling that although employers can conduct internal disciplinary proceedings independently of criminal cases, they must establish valid reasons before terminating an employee.
The judge observed that the allegations against Musyoka were serious and required sufficient evidence, particularly because the dismissal brought an end to a teaching career that had lasted more than 25 years. TSC had argued that it followed the required disciplinary procedures, including giving Musyoka an opportunity to respond to the accusations. It also maintained that the magistrate had wrongly applied the criminal standard of proof instead of the lower standard used in employment disputes.
The commission further argued that it had a responsibility to protect children from abuse and was therefore entitled to take disciplinary action against the teacher. However, the court maintained that following disciplinary procedures was not enough if the employer could not establish that the reasons for dismissal were fair and valid.
The dispute began in 2017 when Musyoka was accused of sexually harassing a minor identified as W.M. He was interdicted before the commission terminated his employment in 2018. During the disciplinary process, the school Board of Management raised concerns about inconsistencies in the accounts given by the pupil and her mother. The two reportedly gave different dates for the alleged incident, with the pupil identifying January 13, 2017, while her mother indicated February 13, 2017.
The board also questioned the account of a boy who was said to have seen the pupil leaving a bathroom while crying. During questioning, the boy admitted that he had not witnessed the alleged incident but had received the information from the pupil’s brother. The court also considered a medical report that recorded no bruises or cuts on the pupil’s external genitalia and indicated that her hymen was intact.
Musyoka further accused a TSC sub-county human resource officer of influencing the disciplinary process by guiding witnesses and pressuring the school board to take action against him. The judge questioned why the officer had not been called to respond to the allegations.
The court also noted that claims that the teacher had confessed to the misconduct lacked independent supporting evidence. Although the judge agreed that an employer can discipline an employee even after an acquittal in a criminal case, he ruled that TSC still had to justify the termination.
The ruling, delivered on November 13, upheld the Sh975,000 compensation awarded by the magistrate. The amount comprised Sh75,000 in salary in place of notice and Sh900,000 equivalent to 12 months’ salary for unfair termination.


